Sunday 15 November 2009

Are expats without borders?

I recently commented on a blog, which is something I don't really do that often, especially if I don't know the blogger personally. I know - not good 'social networking' practise. Well, that's a topic for another day. Anyway, I won't name the blog as it's not really relevant to the present issue and as I'm going to whine, the owner of the blog may not appreciate being mentioned...

The blog post was something about a certain crafting celebrity not being featured so largely in countries other than her own. A perfectly valid topic and a personal viewpoint, which means it shouldn't really be attacked. I enjoyed the blog post and was intrigued by the ensuing comments. Around 80% of the responses were derisive of the blogger's topic and rudely mocking of the infamous crafter in question. Now, personally, I don't love nor hate that particular celebrity as she is quite far removed from my culture and lifestyle as it is possible to be. Yet, she is doing me no harm! She is firmly and happily ensconced far away from me, Britain and Turkey and is not threatening to turn the Brits into pumpkin-carving, card-making, fifty-layers-of-bedlinen buying fanatics any day soon. So, why should I call her rude names or wish bad things upon her?

However, I felt I should voice my opinion as to why she's not popular in my neighbourhood, but also to say that there was no need to be rude about her. I think being an expat - as well as a cross-breed - kind of gives me the 'live and let live' edge. Don't like a person? Fine, but let it go - there are people that do.

Imagine my surprise, then, when I received a response to my comment from a complete stranger from Germany (not the blogger herself). This person wrote nothing about the celebrity in question, but instead poked fun at my comments about Britain and how her experience during visits to London were so different. I won't repeat the comment, but it made me think. This person is living in her own country, therefore does not experience pining, nostalgia and memories as acutely as we do. This must therefore give her the luxury of being publicly mocking of other cultures and nations. Now, honestly, we all do this in some context, don't we? But, never perhaps directly, or so publicly? And, I've noticed, expats are a little softer around the edges when it comes to discussing other people and nations. There's just that little bit more hesitation before speaking, careful avoidance of anything which may be offensive. Also, there's more defensiveness. You get to experience and appreciate other beliefs and cultures, and respect them. You have no choice but to be open-minded, in the beginning. After all, you are the one 'invading' so to speak.

Anyway, at the end of a very long and derisive talking down, does it ever make sense to end with '...by the way, dont get me wrong, I like London and the British...' Oh, okay. I somehow didn't get that from the 200 words you just spent completely slating the place...

2 comments:

  1. Hi Figen. This is a great question. I'll try to be objective because I know the blog in question and read the commentor's comment to your comment (mouthful!) I would agree that best-case scenario an expat has the willingness to listen and observe. I've met a lot of expats that are jaded, though, and hate their adopted country, so there is the opportunity for extremes. I'm not sure if they are always more open-minded, but being on the outside does lend one to being sensitive to others. As for the blog post itself, I found the comments troubling, personally, as it seemed more of a cry for attention than willingness to join in on a conversation. The blog writer was being honest and I felt got an overwhelmingly negative response (a sentence that didn't fit the crime). Go figure. It didn't really accomplish anything except to reinforce stereotypes of elitism. And maybe only an expat would really notice the tension? How many people were accusatory more than understanding of this particular person's situation? I don't think I have an answer in here, but I'm glad to mull this over, and wish you hadn't faced the brunt of it. Don't let this one situation stop you from interacting: you have so much to share!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for your thoughtful comment, Rose! I'm glad that I'm not the only one who found the comments to the lovely blogger's post quite hysterical and vicious.
    Now, I'm all for some tongue-in-cheek fun-poking here and there, but just because you're online and 'anonymous' doesn't mean that you can be so hurtful and in this case - dare I say - racist.
    My views and memories about my beautiful London may leave others at a loss, but a person shouldn't have to be spiteful to prove me wrong.

    ReplyDelete